top of page

Why I Struggle with Brainstorming Story Ideas for Games When I'm Not a Writer

Writer: Steve MillerSteve Miller

As a gaming enthusiast, I am passionate about immersing myself in the worlds crafted by skilled writers. The characters, plot twists, and emotional journeys are what truly captivate me about gaming. However, when I try to brainstorm my story ideas, I frequently hit a wall. It’s a real challenge: how can I, with no formal writing experience, create compelling narratives for games? This is my journey to tackling this challenge along with some practical tips for others like me.


The Weight of Expectations


One major hurdle for me is the weight of expectations. There is a subtle pressure to produce something unique and engaging. Consuming a wide range of stories raises my standards, often causing anxiety that my ideas won't hold a candle to complex narratives like those in Heavy Rain or The Last of Us.


This self-imposed pressure is compounded by the gaming community, which can be both fierce and discerning. When I share ideas with friends, I worry they might think my concepts are silly or lack depth. For example, in a recent discussion, I hesitated to share an idea about a character having a psychotic episode during a musical performance, fearing it might seem unoriginal or cliched.

Muscular man holding barbells

Embracing the Blank Page & Brainstorming Ideas


When I finally sit down to brainstorm story ideas, I am confronted with a daunting blank page. It often feels like a void that threatens to consume my creativity. Brainstorming can be intimidating, especially when every empty space seems to mock my struggle.


To overcome this, I’ve learned to embrace my chaotic thoughts. Instead of trying to build a cohesive storyline from the start, I jot down snippets of dialogue, character names, or even intriguing settings as they come to me. For instance, I might write down a phrase like "a village hidden in perpetual mist" or "a rogue who can manipulate shadows." This method allows me to gather raw inspiration without the pressure of forming a complete idea immediately. While there may be some who disagree with this method, I find putting my ideas through generative AI such as Chat GPT can help me to articulate my ideas, come up with new iterations quickly, and even ask questions I hadn't even thought of. Is AI writing the story for me? The short answer is no. It's more of a collaboration. I come up with the ideas, and it helps me put them into words, and sometimes even gives me new inspiration.

Image of a person's hand, writing in a notebook

Seeking Inspiration in Unusual Places


I have realized that inspiration can be found in many places. Instead of relying solely on video games, I have expanded my search to movies, books, and real-life experiences. Watching a compelling film can spark ideas that I hadn’t anticipated.


For example, while watching a documentary about survival stories, I became captivated by the resilience of individuals facing extreme odds. This led me to envision a game where players must build alliances in a post-apocalyptic world—a blend of survival and strategy that incorporates human connection. By weaving elements from various media, I can enrich my narratives and explore diverse storytelling styles.


Holding a Playstation controller in front of a TV


The Joy of Collaboration


Another avenue that has proven helpful for brainstorming is collaboration. As someone without a formal writing background, I sometimes lack confidence in fleshing out narratives on my own. However, talking through ideas with fellow gamers often reignites my creativity.


I remember brainstorming with friends about some of the different information to include in the Character Bio's. Discussing character backstories and potential plot twists led to a dynamic exchange of ideas, each one sparking the next. This collaborative spirit made the process enjoyable and reminded me that storytelling is a shared experience.

Two people collaboration with laptops and papers

Learning to Let Go


A significant challenge in my brainstorming journey has been learning to let go of the notion that I must come up with the "perfect" idea. I often obsess over whether my storylines are polished or original enough, stifling my creativity. This common struggle among aspiring storytellers has made me wary of sharing even my drafts.


Over time, I realized that even the most successful games began as rough concepts. For example, Minecraft, a game enjoyed by millions, started as a simple block-building project. By allowing myself to play with incomplete ideas and embracing imperfections, I discovered a more open-minded approach to creativity.

A garbage can filled with crumpled papers

Final Thoughts on Story Ideas


Brainstorming story ideas can seem overwhelming when you aren't a writer, but it doesn't have to be a daunting task. By facing expectations, embracing randomness, seeking collaborative input, letting go of perfection, and playing with different concepts, I have rediscovered my joy in the creative process. Ultimately, storytelling is accessible to everyone; you don’t need a degree in writing to engage with it.


For fellow gaming enthusiasts feeling the same struggle, I encourage you to nurture your ideas, no matter how wild they may seem. Remember, every iconic game begins with a spark of creativity, and you may uncover your next favorite gaming adventure in the process.

 
 
 

Comments


  • alt.text.label.Facebook
  • alt.text.label.Instagram
  • X
  • Youtube
  • IndieDB

©2023 Chasing Windmills Games LLC

bottom of page